TOM - I saw a program
on the history channel devoted solely to the possible
locations of Eden. One claim, that made sense to me
was that Eden was located just to the west of the
Persian Gulf now surround by and what is known as
Iraq, Iran, and Kuwait. The reason this location is so
appealing to many is due to the fact that the four
surrounding and connecting rivers and ancient river
beds are congruent with those mentioned in the Old
Testament account. Also the terrain and vegetation,
specifically fruit and fig trees are very prominent
there. Is there any evidence that would
support the Garden of Eden being in Jackson County as the Church claims?
JOEL - First of all, knowing the exact location of the Garden
of Eden is not essential for the salvation of mankind
and is therefore classified more as Mormon trivia
rathar than as an "official" truth or Church doctrine.
Latter-day scripture does not categorically pinpoint
the location of the Garden of Eden, but it does place
Adam in the Western Hemisphere-stating that he dwelt
at Adam-ondi-Ahman-and speaks particularly of Spring
Hill in Daviess County, Missouri, as the place where
Adam shall come to a future council meeting (see D&C
78:15; 116:1; 117:8). Drawing on this information,
early Latter-day Saints concluded that the area now
called the state of Missouri is the place where Adam
and Eve dwelt after their expulsion from the garden.
There are no existing documents containing a specific
declaration in the words of Joseph Smith in which he
gave the exact location of the Garden of Eden, but
several secondary sources report that he did so.
Presidents Brigham Young, Heber C. Kimball, and Joseph
Fielding Smith all said that Joseph Smith taught that
the Garden of Eden was located in Jackson County,
Missouri, where the city of Independence now is.
President Joseph Fielding Smith said:
According to Wilford Woodruff, President Brigham Young
once said: "Joseph, the Prophet, told me that the
Garden of Eden was in Jackson County, Missouri.
When Adam was driven out he went to the place we now
call Adam-ondi-Ahman, Daviess County, Missouri. There
he built an altar and offered sacrifices."
(Heber C. Kimball, in Journal of Discourses 10:235.)
Speaking in Provo, Utah, in 1863, Heber C. Kimball
discussed several things about Adam and about the
redemption of the earth. As one of his points he said:
"The spot chosen for the garden of Eden was Jackson
County, in the state of Missouri, where Independence
now stands; it was occupied in the morn of creation
by Adam and his associates who came with him for the
express purpose of peopling this earth." President
Kimball further commented that "the Prophet Joseph
frequently spoke of these things in the revelations
which he gave, but the people generally did not
understand them."
(Joseph Fielding Smith, Doctrines of Salvation, comp.
Bruce R. McConkie, 3 vols. (Salt Lake City: Bookcraft,
1954-56), 3:74.)
The rivers spoken of in Genesis and in the Book of
Moses are rivers that existed when all the waters of
the earth were in one place. If all the waters
were in one place, then obviously all the land was in
one place (Gen. 1:9).
This was before the days of the flood. There can be no
question that during the flood great changes were made
on the face of the earth. The land surface was in the
process of division into continents. The
rivers mentioned in Genesis were rivers that existed
in the garden of Eden long before the land was divided
into continents and islands(Gen. 10: 25). The flood covered the
entire earth, including those ancient rivers. After
the flood, sedimentary layers sometimes miles thick
may have buried forever the pre-Flood world, including
the original Tigris and Euphrates rivers. Therefore,
today's Tigris and Euphrates may have been named after
the original pre-Flood rivers but may not be in the
same place.
I think because of the above information, as far as I know,
there have been no attempts to find physical evidence to
support the claim of the Garden of Eden being in Jackson County, Missouri.