JOHN - This is a sincere question—not meant to “cast doubt” etc... The
church is well known for its statistical analysis of numerous issues:
convert baptisms and retention, missionary efforts and baptisms, level
of education and church activity rate etc... Do you know if a
non-biased study has ever been done with regards to purely faith based issues
such as priesthood blessings and recovery rates of certain illnesses
such as cancer etc... For example—Wouldn’t a community with a large,
active LDS population be expected to have a better illness recovery
rate than a similar “non-LDS” community with all other things being
equal (demographics, access to similar health care etc...)? This is
assuming that most with a specific illness within the “active” LDS
community have exercised their faith by receiving a priesthood blessing for
the sick.
It’s easy for statisticians to show cause-and-effect with issues such
as member missionary work and convert baptism rates, so why not with
issues like prayer and priesthood blessings which are based on faith and
righteousness. It would seem that there should definitely be a
correlation. If there is no measurable correlation, then it appears that all
blessings are just based on hard work and real faith plays little
role. One could argue that it takes faith to do hard work, but many
non-believing atheists work hard and haven’t the faith to move a mustard
seed, much less a mountain. I realize that correlations exist between
families praying together and youth retention rates, teenage pregnancy
etc... , but this is not what I’m referring to. There are many more
variables when looking at those types of issues. But issues purely
involving faith, because all other works have been exhausted, are what I’m
asking about.
JOEL - As far as I know there have been no studies performed
on this subject, nor do I think there ever will be.
God answers the faithful prayers of both LDS and
non-LDS, so I doubt that the prevalance of such things
could be identified only within LDS communities. Also
often times priesthood blessings and faith-based
healings are considered sacred experiences to be kept
private; not something that would be shared through
some sort of poll.
While on the earth Jesus often healed in private and
then departed. When He healed, He often charged, "See
thou tell no man; but go thy way" (Matthew 8:4; see
also Luke 8:56).
Priesthood blessings allow us to call on the powers of
God, as well as our faith, to change a changeable
condition or situation, that would have continued had
we not given the blessing; so long as that person is
not appointed to experience the trial.
In regards to the outcome of priesthood blessings God
tells us:
“And again, it shall come to pass that he that hath
faith in me to be healed, and is not appointed unto
death, shall be healed” (D&C 42:48).
All too often people overlook the qualifying phrase
“and is not appointed unto death” (“or,” we might add,
“unto sickness or handicap”).
Sometimes priesthood blessings are given simply to
help the person survive the illness or problem rather
than to cure them. What might seem as a failure of the
priesthood to heal is simply an opportunity for the
person to grow in character and prove his faith in the
face of adversity.
The scriptures tell us that faith without works is
dead (James 2: 17, 20, 26), so of course God wants us
to do do all we can for ourselves to improve our
situation, but I don't see how one can prove that
faith or the priesthood play no part in the healing
process.
God gives this great promise for those who exercize
their faith by the giving and receiving of priesthood
blessings:
"And the elders of the church, two or more, shall be
called, and shall pray for and lay their hands upon
them in my name; and if they die they shall die unto
me, and if they live they shall live unto me." (D&C
42:44 )
So the way I see it priesthood blessings help
regardless of the outcome. With all the different
situations and outcomes that are possible with
priesthood and faith-based healings, I don't see how
such a thing could be quantified.
My own personal experience with this has me convinced
that priesthood and faith deffinately make a
difference when it comes to healing the sick, when all
works have been exhausted.